Welcome to Mamma Maria
Mamma Maria, located at 40 Washington St in West Orange, NJ, is a culinary gem that transcends traditional dining expectations. Renowned for its exceptional customer service, the owner often goes above and beyond to ensure a personalized experience. Diners rave about the fresh and flavorful dishes, particularly the pasta and meatballs with rich gravy, as well as the stunning Margherita pizza. Delivery is handled with care, making every order a delight. Whether you're indulging in their specialty pizzas or trying the delectable Zeppolis, Mamma Maria consistently impresses with its quality and warmth, making it a beloved local establishment.
Mamma Maria: Reviews & Ratings
I love it here Great food Friendly service
Ordered delivery tonight the owner took my order listened to my needs told me a special they had and then added my sausage for me on the pizza. The order was delivered with no sausage and the owner called apologized and personally delivered me a pizza with Sausage. He went above and beyond and the food was fresh hot and amazing.... Thank you for dinner mama Maria’s!!!!! I’ve been ordering for years he knew me my phone number and address and the order placing was so personal and appreciated
We are in NJ from Ohio. The food was absolutely amazing!!! The pasta and meatballs with delicious gravy was so good and there was so much of it! The Marguerita pie is stunning and fantastic! Finally the man who took our order in the phone and who brought the delivery was a great guy! Win win win!
I've been ordering from them for a month now. And every time I get my delivery, the food comes hot, all utensils, all sauces and cheese. The way they pack the food is with care. I mean...I don't have 1 bad thing to say and that's impressive!! Well, went today, in person, since I've never been...and surprised to learn that they aren't Italian! In either case, the food is absolutely DELISH! We haven't had 1 bad dish!! Although, not the best wings, they also aren't the worst. But pasta dishes are the BEST! Really flavorful and absolutely delish! Thanks guys for always providing amazing food and always packing with everything needed! Give them a try!
Love the experience here had a buffalo chicken pizza that was warmed to perfection. Any speciality pizza from this place especially BUFFALO chicken is good. Don’t forget the Zeppoli’s. With the powder sugar...fresh and hot out the oven. 9.5/10 I usually go lunch hour which isn’t too crowded but you can also eat inside the location.
The pizza was amazing!!! The beat ive had in yrs. All the ingredients were so fresh especially the bread and crust. My entire family enjoyed it. This will be my main pizza place from now on
Pizza and hot subs the BEST. Nice people.
Definitely my favorite place to eat now. The Grilled chicken Caesar pizza is so filling and very affordable. I personally recommend it! The Buffalo Chicken Ranch Pizza is just as awesome if you like spicy food.
Location
-
40 Washington St, West Orange, NJ 07052, United States Hotline: +1 973-731-0632
Welcome to Mamma Maria, a delightful culinary gem nestled in West Orange, NJ, at 40 Washington St. This inviting eatery has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike, not just for its delicious offerings but for its warm and welcoming atmosphere. With a phone number of +1 973-731-0632, Mamma Maria is easily accessible, whether you dine in or opt for delivery.
One of the most praised aspects of Mamma Maria is its exceptional service. Customers have shared stories illustrating just how far the team goes to ensure a wonderful experience. For instance, a delivery mishap turned into a personal delivery of a corrected order, showcasing the commitment of the owner to customer satisfaction. This level of service is a recurring theme in reviews, with many noting how staff take the time to get to know their regular customers.
The menu at Mamma Maria is a symphony of flavors that resonates with anyone who appreciates hearty, homemade cuisine. Guests rave about the pasta and meatballs, elegantly doused in a rich, flavorful gravy that leaves a lasting impression. The Margherita pizza is another highlight, often described as stunning and fantastic, boasting fresh ingredients and an impeccable crust. And let's not overlook the customer-favorite buffalo chicken pizza, known for its perfectly warmed toppings and scrumptiously satisfying flavors.
Mamma Maria goes the extra mile in presentation and care for its food. One customer expressed admiration for the meticulous packing of delivery orders, ensuring every sauce and utensil is included, which demonstrates a commitment to providing a complete dining experience. This attention to detail is indicative of a larger philosophy at Mamma Maria: to treat every customer like family.
Moreover, returning patrons can attest to the consistency of quality at Mamma Maria. Many have shared that their experiences with the food have only improved over time, which is a testament to the dedication of the kitchen staff. Whether you visit for a hearty entrée or indulge in the delightful zeppoles dusted with powdered sugar, there's a sense of joy that accompanies each dish.
In essence, Mamma Maria is not just a restaurant; it encapsulates the concept of home-cooked Italian comfort food with a personal touch. With rave reviews and a devoted following, this West Orange treasure is sure to provide an unforgettable dining experience, promising satisfaction from the first bite to the last. So, the next time you're in the area, do yourself a favor and experience all that Mamma Maria has to offer—you won’t be disappointed!